Tsuki ga Michibiku Isekai Douchuu review

Ekhein10
Apr 03, 2021
|Well while generally speaking i liked this manga, characters seemed good but there is one but, I came to realization that Male Lead is an utter garbage...In spoiler section i will thoroughly explain with some chapter references why he is bad not like fictional character but as a real human being.

Story 8/10

Well it has(had) some nice comedy elements but they start to grow dull when you understand serious note is mixed up with comedy while it should have it's charm but the comedy is childish. World building well it's was a nice breeze of something new (and not so new), medieval fantasy setting with more elements based on other side (demi humans). While we have encounters with humans they are mostly shown the ugly side the endless discrimination towards demi humans and etc.
Story starts of with our ML being sent to other world by god of Moon, she gave him her blessing and sent him to other world god who quickly insults him by calling him ugly and saying she doesn't need him, she gives him her blessing (power to speak to demi humans but not humans) and orders him not to mingle with beautiful races (humans and elves i presume) and ports him to the edge of world.......
All in all set and setting is good and relaxing there no unnecessary drama or even if there is it is quickly resolved but the biggest hurdle in this story is our ML who treats everything like a child or person playing a game. World setting is a fight humans against demons with heroes and other fantasy isekai manga troupes though it has some uniqueness to it and definitely was interesting for me even after a lot of other isekai mangas.
While the story and world looks quite grimm with a lot of devious stuff shown to reader we see our ML trying to throw dust of virtue to us but his virtue signalling is nothing more than a child with godlike powers who doesn't understand a thing about world around and tries to project his world view all around while he thinks that he is integrating.
As for others support and background characters they seem like more human or at least with more processing power even though they have face value shortcomings shown to us unlike ML who has a lot of shortcomings but they are deep very deep and wide.
It's like author created a great story with a lot of potential then placed a turd in the middle and called it ML, it has only one objective smear everything it sees.


Art 7/10

Well while characters themselves were drawn mostly accurately and detailed author decided to make almost everything humanoid, background wise well there were moderate amounts of blanks (black and white voids). Panel placement and speech bubbles up to standards no confusion was found


Characters 6/10

Well here we have a biggest minus of this manga and this is our ML, indecisive, kind, dumb, naive, arrogant(later on), oblivious and actually bad personality if you delve deeper on analysis in spoiler section i will devout everything about him and other 2 heroes in retrospect. This ML is basically dragging the whole manga through mud if author would make somebody more realistic or less childish maybe this manga would be in my personal top but when such a weak character play the Main....well he simply drags everything to the bottom.
Next we have 2 other heroes whose flaws are shown right at the start as we meet them, while they do have flaws you see them grow or descend, trying to mend their flaws or open them wider, thinking of something smart or plainly cowardly but they seemed to be more up to their ages and human with some realistic views on a new world so at some point it was more interesting to follow around other heroes or supports than our ML.
Supports are actually playing a big role in this manga, they scheme, they find solutions they live in this world. Our ML supporting cast is amazing and feels like their loyalty is misplaced our MC has absurd amounts of mana but other than that he seems unremarkable basically everything is done by supporting cast while ML is simply dragged by his fallowers while when he has some initiative childish and random at best, his kindness and ever forgiveness are annoying because it backfires the higher you go up the ladder of power + it's more annoying when you start to understand that he is actually tyrannical(there were signs).
Supports of other 2 heroes, well there is at least an objective explanation to their loyalty.
In conclusion the only *odd* element we see is our ML if he was different or would not exist i think story would be much better.

Enjoyment 6/10

I enjoyed it but I opened notepad every time i saw some idiocy from ML had to write which chapter and what exactly, i could not simply read and fully immerse myself because of that silly excuse of a human being other than that i didn't see anything so troubling..........so yeah i enjoyed it but there was quite a big thorn there.

Overall 7/10

Would i advice to read it? Yes, if you like isekai fantasy but if you hate undeserving, servile and plainly dumb Main Leads then stray away from this manga this manga basically was created for some hikikomori or cast from school to play with their ego and tell them a story about even if you utter nothing some magic stuff still happen to you.........SIMPLY F NO in order for something to change or good to happen to you, you should grown and change.






SPOLER ARERT BELOW---------------------------------------------------------------






Finally some real bashing before chapter 25 i was still ok with MC yes he still was bad for me but endurable but now we will a chapter breakdown:
Chapter 25-26 our main was ambushed and enemy tried to kill him, they even tried to coerce his servant well of course they did not succeed but after beating opponents they didn't kill anyone even spared them then helped the main ambusher to receive a pardon from influential merchant why the pardon? Well MC decided to help with a quest but apparently all adventurers had an agreement not to help that merchant (but our MC didn't know he was a new arrival to the town) so the main ambusher without talking or other means decided to ambush with intent of killing or injuring them all to teach them a lesson.
Next after breaking evil guys sword our MC decided to compensate with a dwarven rare and expensive sword.
Is this problem? Well yeah, think about if someone were to ambush you and your family members on picnic with intent to kill or injure and if you aren't strong enough they do just that, basically speaking moral of the story if you are a badie and you are beaten a good guy always will spare you and even give you a reward for being a baddie?!
Chapter 32 you how shounen like to be innocent well this shounen is close to seinen, but apparently it's shounen only around our MC around him we see plenty of seinen content, you know other hero who was summoned he is 15y old an already had sex but our MC is chaste he finds any reason not to go this side - followers=family, acquaintances=remind of girls of his world and so on, why i see a problem well shounen usually doesn't show and romance or explicit content or at the very least shows that everyone has it do a degree but our MC is like a UNICORN that shits shounen content all over the place.
chapter 37-38. Refusal to have sex but being slightly coerced by a*prostitute*(it's actually the opposite prostitute then refusal). Hey if you are almost an adult so if you have pent stuff going on help yourself or let others help you he seems like a child who experienced arousal for the first time. Next we have when he is attacked he doesn't shown any strength that he apparently has so what does he do?(remember he one punched a cerberus) Right flee, i'm not saying you should kill but block attacks and try talk to resolve and once again he is saved by his followers.
Chapter 40 Once again we see that someone planned to kill our MC but he still shrugged it off because he was unharmed and even invites those people to join his village.........What if someone was weaker than him? They would murder that person so he is apologetic to all kinds of scum of that world.
Chapter 41 Mc is being kind and diplomatic with a Lich that basically feeds of from living creatures and i presume tortured people too. Not even diplomatic but servile to a degree. What i noticed he tries to act all servile and kind to strangers who insult him or his followers but he can be stern and angry with his loyal followers ain't a bit hypocritical?
By now it is established that MC has low self esteem, naive, dumb, forgiving, kind while he seems to have libido he proactively rejects advances (except by 1), oblivious to feelings of others (lack of empathy) and timid. While he tries to uphold virtue his virtue doesn't discern between evil and good, for example if MC were to meet a maniac or pedophile after he defeats them and they suddenly change their ways he will send them off with expensive gift - It's shounen so demography wise it teaches kids to become idiots as they grow up to adulthood.
Chapter 41 page 6 Lich thinks "He even remembered a minor detail" needless glorifying meaning that wasn't a minor detail, considering that he killed a person right in front of your eyes someone who would forget after a few hours the reason for murder would be considered mentally challenged at the very least.
Humility and pride, pride well he doesn't have it as for humility well no he has slave mentality or a mentality of a child with a big sword who doesn't know a thing about swords.
Chapter 49 Refusal to kill murderers (killed bunch of people + a pregnant woman) it's basically like watching batman or superman, evil guys kill and injure people, good guy steps in puts them in prison, they break out and rinse and repeat.
Chapter 56 Doesn't try to convey correct words to end conflict, presumably has enough mana to match goddess but he could not defeat lvl 920 human (his followers 1320 and 1500 he defeated well at least he could hurt a dragon) eventually he defeats them but is severely damaged off and this happened because he was far away from his followers (because they usually resolve every problem).
Chapter 60 Merciful to bad people again and like he told to his follower "That was move by emotion(decision to save a girl) if you want to correct it you have to do it force(correct his behaviour), so he can be arrogant and knows he is powerful though he usually acts servile around strangers a garbage dumpster he is. A classical case of a grown up who bashes his family or at least acts bad around them while to the outsiders he is people pleaser.
The more i delve to analysis of this subject the more i feel like author actually orchestrated this or simply is oblivious to this frankenstein of creation of his.
Donar
0
0
0

comentarios

Tsuki ga Michibiku Isekai Douchuu
Tsuki ga Michibiku Isekai Douchuu
Autor Kino, Kotora
Artista