Story -
To be honest the only part of Vagabond I cannot call amazing is the story, the pacing is funky, the arcs don't blend too well and in most arc all you are doing is waiting for the climaxing huge event. Overall it at least has one that makes sense and doesn't leave you thinking "ok,,, what was that". 7/10

Art -
Impossible to point out any flaws. The art in Vagabond is incomparable to anything else I've seen and is hard to put into words. 10/10.

Characters -
There are both fun and enjoyable characters (Matahachi) and serious and well evolved characters (Musachi). Enough said. Musachi's evolution with his ideas of strength and what it means to live by a sword are both meaningful and impactful to the reader. 9/10.

Enjoyment -
10/10. Enjoyment is hard to put into words so very simply: I had fun; I laughed; I serioused; I sadded; I was amazed.