To say the least, I enjoyed reading WMMAP. It’s a refreshing story that focuses more on the father-daughter relationship and less on romance. We’re made aware of the reasons for Claude’s initial hate for Athy. Just like Athy, at first, I hated him for killing original Athanasia. As the story progresses and as his motivation was revealed, I couldn’t help but empathize with him.

Athy really doesn’t have any lofty ideals and frankly, I can’t think of anything about her personality that stands out. She simply wants to survive and live until 18 and perhaps as a result of her previous life, she doesn’t have much expectations. Sure, she does like sparkly things and was delighted when she was given a treasury key, she doesn’t really make it her goal of obtaining it. She doesn’t desire to be loved and is perfectly fine without it. She’s very much independent and strangely, has decent morals. However, I don’t see her as someone as kind as a saint. She has no qualms in insulting Roger Alpehus, because she sees him as someone manipulative. On the other hand, she is very kind towards people that wouldn’t bring her harm and is very vocal about her dislike of someone, if it doesn’t harm her life. Athy is very clear that she would do anything to survive.

For people who want to see the protagonist undergo major character change, Athy would definitely not fit your tastes. I don’t see her as Mary Sue. However, she definitely doesn’t have any fatal character flaw.

For anyone who has read too much isekai about a girl wanting to escape her destiny of getting killed, this story would bore you. Just like what I’ve said, it doesn’t introduce anything new nor does it subvert your expectations. You could easily find the characters in WMMAP in any other story. Perhaps the only redeeming factor about this story is its outstanding art and decent development. One thing’s for sure, the author knows what foreshadowing is. At the very least, the characters have their own motivations that are otherwise hard to realize unless you look carefully.

WWMAP is at best, average and at worst, bland. Nevertheless, it was a good read.